Water - Stays slick very long, much longer than I have needed anyway. It doesn't get sticky when it does start to dry it just absorbs into my skin like lotion. No smell and no tastes, 9.5/10.
Fire - Also stays slick much longer than I needed, the warming is very nice and, although subtle, it is very intense on the genetles. It gets slightly sticky when dry but no big deal. No smell but it does have an unplesent taste, 9/10 because of taste.
Ice - Same as Water when it comes to duration and drying. The tingling is very intense and I loved it. The only thing I don't like is the fact that it smells heavily of menthol and tastes like it too, also it made it sting slightly the next time I had to piss. This one gets a 8/10 because of the forementioned down sides.
Just an added note it is not quite as thick as ID but not as thin as Astroglide. Over all a great product from ILF and would recomend it to anyone I know.